Phuket island hopping tour suggestion

Hello everyone, 

I need your suggestions who went for island hopping from phuket or somebody who booked GetYourGuide packages. 

I go through so many options but narrow down to these 2 pacakges and now I am little confused: 

1. [https://www.getyourguide.com/phuket-l32123/phuket-phi-phi-an

2. [https://www.getyourguide.com/phuket-l32123/phuket-full-day-j

Can anybody suggest me among these two , which one would be better for a first timer? As who went on these places and guide me with their experience.

Note : I am not a swimmer.